15 Comments
User's avatar
William Collen's avatar

All writers should do this sort of self-analysis and graph-making, because it's fun!

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

Self-indulgence generally is!

Expand full comment
Stirling S Newberry's avatar

Peahens nest on the ground or occasional in a tree.

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

Amazing news, thank you!

Expand full comment
Stirling S Newberry's avatar

Random knowledge. I look forward to your next installment.

Expand full comment
Stetson's avatar

Are you familiar with the Social Brain Hypothesis? I'm of the understanding it's the preferred explanation for the 2.5M years of brain evolution responsible for our cerebral volumes being 3X that of our nearest extant cousins (chimps). Michael Muthukrishna (LSE Prof) also has a nice extension of SBH called the cultural brain hypothesis.

There are some clear parallels I think you can draw from.

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

I actually have heard of this, or at least the Dunbar number—just wasn’t making the connection

Expand full comment
Stetson's avatar

Yes, Dunbar, if I'm not mistaken, is the originator of the Social Brain Hypothesis. I should have included his name in my original comment.

What I think is relevant to you are the ideas about gossip (social information beneficial to group) and deception (strategies useful to individuals undermining the group). This 'arms race" is the alleged impetus behind the selection for greater intelligence in humans.

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

Intriguing for sure. Is there a specific book or article you’d recommend?

Expand full comment
Stetson's avatar

There's a chapter in Max Bennett's A Brief History of Intelligence that provides very nice coverage.

Hoel's review of Graeber/Wengrow's book The Dawn of Everything has some good points on gossip's role in deep human history and today - https://open.substack.com/pub/erikhoel/p/the-gossip-trap?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=2jsvs

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

I’m not! Thanks, will check out.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Very useful essay, Natasha, for me to contemplate as I evolve my won writing. Look forward to part two.

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

Useful! Oh no. (Kidding; thanks!)

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

I apologize for touching a nerve as “useful” is status disparaging from a Veblenesque perspective. As you well know!

Expand full comment
a. natasha joukovsky's avatar

No need! I just couldn’t resist

Expand full comment